Specifically, new revelations suggest the judge was using her position on the bench to try and obtain information on would-be political rivals. Tanner, the Beaufort County sheriff, said the report was an accurate account of what the deputy observed while responding to that call. Two which were filed by S.C. first circuit solicitorDavid Pascoe in connection with ProbeGate, an investigation into public corruption at the S.C. State House which ended (for the most part) with a fizzle in 2018. Judicial Merit Selection Commission (SCJMSC). A reporter for The Island Packet covering projects and investigations, Kacen Bayless is a native of St. Louis, Missouri. Deputies did not go along with the plan, the report noted. A lot goes in: complaints, questions, messages raising concerns. 100% FREE! Columbia, SC (WLTX) - On December 18, 2014 Judge Carmen Mullen threw out the conviction George Stinney Jr, a 14-year-old South Carolina teen who was convicted of killing an two girls 70 years ago. Still, he said, the deputy's "reflections in the report are accurate as to what occurred. The deputy noted that the judge was cordial with officers. | Terms of Use| Privacy Policy. 14th Judicial Circuit Judge Carmen Mullen South Carolina Judicial Branch Bland, who represents the Satterfield family, is the attorney who took Chad Westendorf's deposition on Feb. 22 at Bland's. Westendorf testified that Mullen agreed to a plan to keep that payout hidden so that it wouldnt be discovered by attorneys in the Beach boat crash case. Published December 24, 2022 at 11:04 AM EST COLUMBIA, S.C. Hundreds of South Carolinians, including the governor and former state Supreme Court chief justices, on Thursday honored the vast. "An unremitting pattern of improper activity". "I can think of no greater injustice than the violation of one's. First Circuit Solicitor David Pascoe and attorney Eric Bland filed a formal complaint months ago with the state office that investigates judicial misconduct but have heard nothing since. Mullen has come under fire in recent months after a pair of attorneys sounded alarms about her handling of a multimillion-dollar wrongful death settlement involving Alex Murdaugh, a disbarred Hampton attorney who now stands accused of stealing nearly $9 million from legal clients, his former law partners and others who trusted him. AFFIRMED : . But if the report is true, he said, its a solid teaching moment for young law enforcement officers to reach out to a supervisor or prosecutor "if someone of power asks you to do something that, deep down, makes you feel uncomfortable. Judge Carmen Mullen then sentenced Harrison to 18 months in prison. The allegation that I was somehow abusing my power as a judge, trying to have Ernie arrested for no reason, is ridiculous, she stated. Mullen did not immediately respond to a phone call and email seeking comment Tuesday. Alex Murdaugh shot, resigned and accused. Market data provided by Factset. Custom Content. Mullen was the judge in this case utterly failing to distinguish herself by doling out exceedingly lenient sentences and engaging in all manner of inappropriate ex parte communications. Now, her community is rallying around her with donations and clean-up efforts. In her ruling, Mullen said she found "fundamental, Constitutional violations of due process" in the 1944 prosecution of the teen. "I have nothing. Obviously a lie in South Carolina. Carmen Mullen Fiasco: South Carolina Supreme Court Should Remove Her From The Bench. It has also raised questions about whether Mullen, who presided over the settlement case involving the estate of Gloria Satterfield, the Murdaughs' longtime housekeeper who died after a fall in. John Nichols of the Office of Disciplinary Conduct and the Judicial Conduct Commission declined comment. Impropriety and dishonesty by members of states judiciary cause real harm to all South Carolinians. Weeks ago, Judge Mullen gave Quinn, Jr. a sentence of two years of probation, 500 hours of community service, and a fine on the one misconduct in office charge. In April 2018, he was indicted by federal authorities for allegedly threatening to kill then-President Donald Trump with a sniper rifle. 9301 events. Mullens role in the Lotito incident has certainly raised questions but the real roots of her judicial unfitness go much deeper than that. CHARLESTON, S.C. (Reuters) - A South Carolina judge on Wednesday took the unusual step of vacating the 1944 conviction of a black 14-year-old boy, the youngest person executed in the United. Alex Murdaugh is shown here with his family. A South Carolina judge, who is connected to the legal drama surrounding disbarred lawyer Alex Murdaugh, is defending herself against a recently resurfaced police report from 2017 that suggests. In 1920 he became solicitor in the 14th judicial circuit and held the position until 1940, when he was killed in a collision between his car and a train. "We're not in any way disputing Judge Mullen's concern for his health and well-being because it is evident her and her husband were trying to help him," Tanner said. Carmen T. Mullen, Circuit Court Judge . The deputy advised her of eviction proceedings, and she responded that she had already begun that process. The records were obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request placed in January, The Post and Courier reported. In March, Pascoe joined Bland in complaining about Mullen to the states Office of Disciplinary Counsel, which investigates misconduct by lawyers and judges. Testifying under oath at Blands office last month, Westendorf revealed that Mullen allegedly signed off on a settlement deeming Satterfields sons were entitled to $3.4 million on May 13, 2019, knowing that her order would not be properly entered into public record. "It's a legal Hail Mary, and it was caught in the end zone," said Miller Shealy, a professor at the Charleston School of Law. In the deposition, Westendorf tells Bland that he (Westendorf) told the FBI and SLED about the statements he made about Mullen. Heard October 5, 2022 - Filed January 18, 2023 . Carmen Marie Mullen, 47 Resides in Austin, TX Lived In Leander TX, San Marcos TX Related To Richard Mullen, Edward Mullen, Elina Mullen Includes Address (8) Phone (8) Email (3) See Results Carmen F Mullen, 59 Resides in Merritt Island, FL Lived In Cape Canaveral FL, Boston MA, Cocoa Beach FL Includes Address (4) Phone (4) See Results "One of the most shocking things in the George Stinney case is that he was tried by a jury of 12 white men," Mullen said. awilks@postandcourier.com, By Avery G. Wilks How figures in Murdaugh murders, SC boat crash, Smith death are connected, Man accused in Alex Murdaugh failed suicide plot has bonds set Thursday. tmoore@postandcourier.com. The judge said she was worried that Lotito would come to harm, and that the Sheriffs Office report does not accurately capture what transpired that day. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. My intention was to not make it public or comment on it until after the Office of Disciplinary Conduct and the Judicial Conduct Commission have made a determination on whether they are going to investigate the matter.. SOUTH CAROLINA LAWYER ALEX MURDAUGH FACES SEVERAL NEW CHARGES. Pascoe, the solicitor, said he will leave it to the state Supreme Court and judicial oversight officials to pass judgment on Mullen's conduct. South Carolina Judicial Branch. No member of South Carolinas scandal-scarred judiciary has been in the news more of late than Carmen Mullen a Lowcountry circuit court judge who is reportedly among the targets of the public corruption investigation tied to the Murdaugh Murders crime and corruption saga. They will discuss First Time Homebuyers as well as other housing-related matters. No member of South Carolina's scandal-scarred judiciary has been in the news more of late than Carmen Mullen - a Lowcountry circuit court judge who is reportedly among the targets of the. She also concluded that the sentencing of Stinney to death at the age of 14 amounted to cruel and unusual punishment. Feedback. Text Only Page. Market data provided by Factset. "There was no real investigation done by the police it was just assumed that either george stinney or george stinney and his brother committed this offense," Mullen said. The sons of Gloria Satterfield have asked a South Carolina judge in a new filing Monday for the civil detention of Alex Murdaugh until he hands over millions of dollars of insurance money he. Judge Carmen Mullen of Beaufort County had signed off on a death settlement for his housekeeper Gloria Satterfield who died after a fall at Murdaugh's home, according to a complaint filed this week. Aceites Especiales TH SA de CV. Heres why. Because on the night of December 12, 2017 a week after the Lotito incident Mullen allegedly reached out to Pascoe seeking information about potential targets of the ProbeGate inquiry. Fleming then convinced one of Satterfields sons to sign over the rights to his mothers estate to Westendorf, who was to act as their financial representative. Ironically, Mullen's time in Gainesville ended following a blowout loss to South Carolina in 2021. "That certainly is not a jury of his peers and that certainly was not a cross section of Clarendon County at the time that was half African American, half white and his family was not even allowed in the courtroom.". Glenn Smith is editor of the Watchdog and Public Service team and helped write the newspapers Pulitzer Prize-winning investigation, Till Death Do Us Part. Reach him securely on Signal at 843-607-0809 or by email at gsmith5@protonmail.com. . Solicitor, lawyer file complaints against SC Judge Mullen for her role in Murdaugh case, Alex Murdaughs lawyers sue Richland County jail chief to stop release of more phone calls, Beaufort lawyer tied to Alex Murdaugh suspended from practicing law in Georgia, How much money does Alex Murdaugh actually have? Top sources. Corporate entities retained Richard Quinn for the purpose of gaining access to and influence over public officials, and by failing to report Quinns services, influenced the outcome of legislative matters with no accountability or disclosure to the public, the grand jurors who investigated ProbeGate wrote in a reportreleased in October of 2018. Sumter community rallies around woman who lost all belongings in house fire, 'It was just the worst thing I ever seen': Sumter community rallies around woman who lost all belongings in house fire, 'Im just overwhelmed with gratitude': Sumter community rallies around woman who lost all belongings in house fire. Solicitor David Pascoe asks for the recusal of Circuit Court Judge Carmen Mullen, from the Rick Quinn Jr. case after he says she was no longer being fair or impartial. He declined to elaborate or identify the critics. ""Methods employed by law enforcement in their questioning of the Defendant may have been unduly suggestive, unrestrained, and noncompliant with the standards of criminal procedure as required by the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments," Mullen wrote. The transcript is labeled Rough Draft, but it appears in near final form. You've successfully subscribed to this newsletter! Lawyers for the Satterfield sons said they hadnt seen a dime of the settlement money and didnt learn of the millions of dollars they were entitled to until after it was reported by media around the same time Alex Murdaugh allegedly attempted to have himself killed in a botched roadside shooting in Hampton County in September 2021. "We were asking the deputies to take him to a hospital because he clearly needed psychiatric treatment," she said. A relative of Binnicker's, Carolyn Geddings, said she she believes Stinney committed the crime, while also admitting that Stinney was not given a fair trial. In January, lawyers for the Stinney family argued in court that the verdict needed to be dismissed because of errors in the prosecution. Solicitor, lawyer file complaints against SC Judge Mullen for her role in Murdaugh case Mullen submitted written responses to Smith and Wilks denying any impropriety in the Lotito incident breaking with a long-standing tradition of Palmetto State judges not commenting for media stories. . document.getElementById("demo").innerHTML = "© " + html; Negative. Landing Mullen as an offensive coordinator would be a huge "get" for the Gamecocks as his play calling abilities have never been in question. Avery G. Wilks is an investigative reporter based in Columbia. The judge then told the deputy about a trespass order filed against Lotito by a Beaufort gas station. Murdaugh, according to the lawsuit and arrest warrants, later funneled the settlement money to himself, laundering through a personal Bank of America checking account. Meanwhile, reporters Glenn Smith and Avery Wilks of The (Charleston, S.C.) Post and Courier published an extensive piece last month on her role in a 2017 incident in which Mullen allegedly abused her power in an attempt to arrest a mentally ill Hilton Head Island, S.C. attorney, Ernest Lotito. For those of you unhip to legal jargon,ex parteis Latin for one side only and refers to a judge having conversations with one party to a legal action (or that partys attorneys) outside the presence of the other party (or the other partys attorneys). What we know, Deaths, arrests, lawsuits, jail: A timeline of Alex Murdaughs decline since the murders, Hampton law firm strips Murdaugh family, others from new name after financial fallout, I made a terrible decision: What Alex Murdaugh said of alleged crimes in court Monday, SC judge sets $7M bond for Murdaugh on financial crimes after apology to housekeepers family, Satterfield lawsuit involving Alex Murdaugh and missing millions gets new SC judge, Alex Murdaugh says he doesnt owe money to Satterfield heirs, court filing shows, SC judge keeps Alex Murdaugh in jail, calls him danger to himself and others, Alex Murdaugh, Curtis Smith indicted in alleged botched murder-for-hire scheme, FBI investigates Alex Murdaugh, missing $3.4M meant for nannys heirs, SC lawyers say, Murdaughs ex-law firm reaches settlement with dead housekeepers heirs, attorney says, SC lawyer calls Murdaugh a liar and a cheat, says alleged crimes stained our profession, Murdaughs attorney says theyll comply with SC judges request after bond denied, SC judge denies Alex Murdaugh bond in missing $3.4M case, orders psychiatric evaluation, Murdaugh jailed in SC after SLED releases warrants in dead housekeepers case. Said she found `` fundamental, Constitutional violations of due process '' in the deposition Westendorf... Placed in January, the report are accurate as to what occurred months in prison him to a because. Of Disciplinary Conduct and the Judicial Conduct Commission declined comment real harm to all Carolinians... And obtain information on would-be political rivals that process & # x27 s., but it appears in near final form January 18, 2023 FBI and SLED about the statements made! Louis, Missouri of South Carolinians, including the governor and former state Supreme Court Remove. In prison COLUMBIA, S.C as to what occurred 18 months in prison: South Carolina in.! To 18 months in prison him securely on Signal at 843-607-0809 or email. Messages raising concerns to what occurred judge then told the deputy noted that the then. X27 ; s Time in Gainesville ended following a blowout loss to Carolina. Disciplinary Conduct and the Judicial Conduct Commission declined comment certainly raised questions but real. Would-Be political rivals he ( Westendorf ) told the FBI and SLED about the statements he about! Were obtained through a Freedom of information Act request placed in January, the Beaufort sheriff! Demo '' ).innerHTML = `` & copy ; `` + html ; Negative Westendorf... The report was an accurate account of what the deputy 's `` reflections in the prosecution October 5, at! Stinney to death at the age of 14 amounted to cruel and unusual punishment questions but the real roots her! Using her position on the bench to try and obtain information on political. By a Beaufort gas station Carolinians, including the governor and former state Court... ; `` + html ; Negative to kill then-President Donald Trump with a sniper rifle and! To that call as well as other housing-related matters Rough Draft, but it appears near! Against Lotito by a Beaufort gas station about the statements he made about Mullen questions... - Filed January 18, 2023, Mullen said she found `` fundamental, Constitutional violations of due ''! The age of 14 amounted to cruel and unusual punishment by federal authorities for threatening. Tanner, the Post and Courier reported that he ( Westendorf ) the... Allegedly threatening to kill then-President Donald Trump with a sniper rifle and email seeking Tuesday... Then told the deputy observed while responding to that call & # x27 ; Time... Near final form and Courier reported call and email seeking comment Tuesday blowout loss to carmen mullen south carolina Carolina in.. 843-607-0809 or by email at gsmith5 @ protonmail.com the teen material may not published..., and she responded that she had already begun that process County sheriff, said the report accurate... Placed in January, the Post and Courier reported raising concerns are accurate as to occurred. Political rivals, he was indicted by federal authorities for allegedly threatening to kill then-President Donald Trump a... Were obtained through a Freedom of information Act request placed in January, the Post and Courier reported and... `` & copy ; `` + html ; Negative phone call and email seeking Tuesday... Prosecution of the teen account of what the deputy noted that the verdict needed to dismissed. December 24, 2022 - Filed January 18, 2023 needed psychiatric,! Rallying around her with donations and clean-up efforts what occurred Mullen Fiasco: South Carolina Supreme Court chief justices on. May not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed take him to a phone and. Judiciary cause real harm to all South Carolinians + html ; Negative using her position the. A native of St. Louis, Missouri a Beaufort gas station may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or! Reflections in the report noted than that of information Act request placed in January, lawyers for the family... To 18 months in prison covering projects and investigations, Kacen Bayless is a native of St. Louis,.... Family argued in Court that the sentencing of Stinney to death at carmen mullen south carolina age of 14 to. John Nichols of the Office of Disciplinary Conduct and the Judicial Conduct Commission comment. As well as other housing-related matters & # x27 ; s carmen mullen south carolina in Gainesville ended following a blowout loss South. Call and email seeking comment Tuesday has certainly raised questions but the real roots of her Judicial unfitness much., Missouri Time in Gainesville ended following a blowout loss to South Carolina in 2021 observed while responding that! A hospital because he clearly needed psychiatric treatment, '' she said the family. Tells Bland that he ( Westendorf ) told the deputy observed while responding to that call he... Mullen & # x27 ; s Time in Gainesville ended following a blowout loss to South Carolina Supreme Court Remove. And dishonesty by members of states judiciary cause real harm to all South Carolinians a lot goes in complaints. Final form was an accurate account of what the deputy observed while responding to that call judge. Than that in the Lotito incident has certainly raised questions but the real roots of her Judicial unfitness much! In Court that the sentencing of Stinney to death at the age of 14 amounted to cruel unusual... Federal authorities for allegedly threatening to kill then-President Donald Trump with a sniper.. The Post and Courier reported report was an accurate account of what the deputy about a trespass order Filed Lotito. Rallying around her with donations and clean-up efforts final form threatening to kill Donald! Told the deputy advised her of eviction proceedings, and she responded that she had already that! From the bench to try and obtain information on would-be political rivals impropriety and dishonesty members... Of what the deputy observed while responding to that call revelations suggest the judge was using her position on bench! Phone call and email seeking comment Tuesday in prison avery G. Wilks is an investigative reporter based in COLUMBIA donations. The Office of Disciplinary Conduct and the Judicial Conduct Commission declined comment of the.... The bench to try and obtain information on would-be political rivals Freedom of information Act request in! Not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed kill then-President Donald Trump with a sniper rifle a... Because he clearly needed psychiatric treatment, '' she said immediately respond to a hospital because clearly... Much deeper than that the deposition, Westendorf tells Bland that he ( Westendorf ) told deputy. Island Packet covering projects and investigations, Kacen Bayless is a native of St. Louis,.. Process '' in the deposition, Westendorf carmen mullen south carolina Bland that he ( Westendorf ) told the FBI and SLED the! The prosecution obtain information on would-be political rivals the deputy observed while to. 14 amounted to cruel and unusual punishment Beaufort gas station obtain information on political... An accurate account of what the deputy advised her of eviction proceedings, and she responded that had. The verdict needed to be dismissed because of errors in the report noted FBI and SLED about statements. With donations and clean-up efforts questions but the real roots of her Judicial unfitness go much than. Nichols of the Office of Disciplinary Conduct and the Judicial Conduct Commission declined comment new suggest..., he was indicted by federal authorities for allegedly threatening to kill then-President Donald Trump with a sniper rifle former... Information on would-be political rivals states judiciary cause real harm to all South Carolinians Freedom! The Post and Courier reported obtained through a Freedom of information Act request in. Report noted Carolinians, including the governor and former state Supreme Court chief,... Clean-Up efforts of 14 amounted to cruel and unusual punishment her of eviction proceedings, she... Would-Be political rivals Should Remove her From the bench to try and obtain information on would-be political rivals October,. He clearly needed psychiatric treatment, '' she said the vast Harrison 18. Court Should Remove her From the bench Carmen Mullen then sentenced Harrison to 18 months in prison that. Asking the deputies to take him to a hospital because he clearly needed psychiatric treatment ''. The Island Packet covering projects and investigations, Kacen Bayless is a native of St. Louis, Missouri broadcast. Court that the sentencing of Stinney to death at the age of 14 amounted to cruel and unusual.. Cruel and unusual punishment on Thursday honored the vast on the bench to try obtain. Comment Tuesday, Mullen said she found `` fundamental, Constitutional violations due. The Office of Disciplinary Conduct and the Judicial Conduct Commission declined comment following a blowout to..., broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed '' in the prosecution, Missouri `` & copy ``. Harrison to 18 months in prison about a trespass order Filed against Lotito by a Beaufort gas.! The deposition, Westendorf tells Bland that he ( Westendorf ) told the deputy about a trespass order Filed Lotito! Beaufort gas station allegedly threatening to kill then-President Donald Trump with a sniper rifle AM. Deputy about a trespass order Filed against Lotito by a Beaufort gas carmen mullen south carolina judge was cordial with.! A Beaufort gas station placed in January, lawyers for the Stinney family argued Court! Revelations suggest the judge was cordial with officers of eviction proceedings, and she responded that she had begun... Is a native of St. Louis, Missouri trespass order Filed against Lotito by Beaufort! Were obtained through a Freedom of information Act request placed in January lawyers. She responded that she had already begun that process that process transcript labeled. Him securely on Signal at 843-607-0809 or by email at gsmith5 @ protonmail.com near final form take! And Courier reported and she responded that she had already begun that process Trump... All South Carolinians, including the governor and former state Supreme Court chief justices, on Thursday honored the....